← Energy Realism
Policy2026-11-18· GNews: AFR energy

A Victorian Coalition win will deepen fractures in national power grid - AFR

Image: Adrian Tync / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The article reports that a Victorian Coalition electoral win would reverse state policy on renewable energy and gas generation, creating divergent generation mixes across the National Electricity Market. The result would fracture coordination on the grid, complicating dispatch, transmission planning, and investment signals for new capacity.

Where this fits

This is a reliability and cost story masquerading as a political one. A grid built on weather-dependent renewables needs either firm dispatchable power (gas, coal, or nuclear) or massive overbuild of generation, transmission, and storage to cover calm periods. When states pursue conflicting generation strategies, nobody can optimise the whole system: transmission gets built in the wrong places, firm capacity sits idle in some regions while others scramble, and the total cost of firming rises. Victoria's policy reversal, whether toward gas or away from renewables, is a symptom of the unpriced problem: the renewable transition's cost of firming and system-wide coordination has been left to states to absorb in ad-hoc fashion, rather than designed from the grid's centre.

What it means

A fractured NEM means higher bills, more curtailment of renewable output, and a weaker grid. Each state chasing its own reliability insurance, whether gas reserves, demand management, or storage, is costlier than one national firm backbone. Australia remains locked into this fragmented path because a single, coherent, firm, low-emission generation technology, nuclear, is prohibited by law. The result is a grid built by patchwork state policy, dependent on China for 80 per cent of its renewable hardware, and no clearer on cost or reliability than it was five years ago.

Go deeper on the numbers

The bigger picture

Energy security is national security. This connects to the wider case at Unprepared: Australia's dependence on a strategic rival, and how ready it is for the world that is coming.

The Unprepared series · Part V

The Factory Floor

In 2024, China built over a thousand commercial vessels. The United States built eight. Part V of the Unprepared series.

Reported by GNews: AFR energy. Read the original report ↗

Related coverage

The numbers, as they move

A short, sourced brief when the figures shift: a transmission blow-out, a supply-chain move, a milestone.

Free every week on Substack. Unsubscribe anytime.